Each project arrives with its purpose, milestones and first tasks written out. Here is how the first three read.
Commercial underwriting checklist for every asset
Most underwriting mistakes are omissions rather than bad maths: a forgotten break clause, a service charge shortfall nobody modelled, a roof that needs replacing in year three. A written checklist covering income, leases, tenants, costs, capex, debt and exit, used on every deal, makes the second asset as thorough as the first and lets a reviewer see at a glance what was checked.
First tasks
- List every question your last three underwritings had to answer late
- Group the questions under income, leases, covenant, costs, capex, debt and exit
- Note the document that answers each checklist item
- Run the checklist on one past deal and add what it missed
Assumption book with a source for every input
When a committee asks where the 6.75 percent exit yield or the nine-month void came from, an answer of judgement is not enough. An assumption book records each input, its value, the evidence behind it and the date it was last checked, so every model draws from one place and stale numbers are easy to spot.
First tasks
- Copy the inputs from your latest model into one assumption sheet
- Add a source and an as-at date beside each input
- Flag every input you cannot evidence for a fresh check
- Re-check any assumption older than six months @recurring(monthly:2)
Return hurdles and walk-away rules in writing
Deals have momentum, and without written hurdles the target return quietly drifts down to whatever the bid needs. Writing the minimum unlevered and levered returns, the lowest acceptable covenant score and the expiry exposure you will not take, before the next deal arrives, gives you a reason to stop that is not personal.
First tasks
- Write the return each recent deal was approved at
- Draft minimum returns and hard limits for each sector you underwrite
- Agree the hurdles with your partner or committee chair
- Store the signed note next to the assumption book