Fairness Opinions

Fairness opinions from the banker's seat: scope and conflicts, the analyses behind the fairness book, internal committee review, the opinion letter, shareholder disclosure and the deals where independence is tested hardest.

Free · Mac (Apple silicon) and Windows · v1.0.5 · Other platforms

Then open the Marketplace in the app, search for Fairness Opinions, and click Install. It goes into your own files, and works offline from then on.

What it installs.

1

Pillar

1

Area

50

Projects

201

Starter tasks

🏦 Investment Banking & Advisory

Fairness Opinions

Preparing a fairness opinion: valuation analyses, the bank's internal committee review, disclosure in shareholder documents and independence questions.

  1. Scope and limits of a fairness opinion
  2. Library of public fairness opinion disclosures
  3. Fairness engagement letter scope check
  4. Relationship and conflict disclosure checklist
  5. Information request list for a fairness engagement
  6. Workplan from mandate to opinion delivery
  7. Fairness committee policy summary
  8. Management projections reliance file
  9. Fairness book page standards and templates
  10. Weekly fairness workstream status note
  11. Monthly read of new fairness disclosures
  12. Quarterly watch on fairness litigation and rulings
  13. Assumptions and judgement log during an engagement
  14. Market data refresh up to the opinion date
  15. Version control for fairness book and opinion drafts
  16. Post-engagement fairness debrief
  17. Committee comment themes register
  18. Fairness committee calendar and submission tracker
  19. Choosing the analyses for the fairness book
  20. Trading and transaction reference ranges for fairness
  21. DCF reference range on management's projections
  22. Premiums paid analysis for fairness purposes
  23. Exchange ratio analysis in stock-for-stock deals
  24. Valuing contingent and non-cash consideration for fairness
  25. Drafting assumptions and limitations in the opinion letter
  26. Proxy summary of the financial analyses
  27. Delivering a fairness opinion orally to a board
  28. Fixed or contingent fairness fee decision
  29. Whether a special committee needs a second opinion
  30. Relying on management's case or asking for another
  31. Choosing the opinion date and bring-down approach
  32. Fairness book checking protocol
  33. Defining the holders the opinion addresses
  34. Pre-committee issues memo
  35. Fairness committee meeting preparation
  36. Board meeting at which the opinion is delivered
  37. Signing-night opinion letter delivery
  38. Shareholder document filing and regulator comments
  39. Shareholder vote and proxy adviser questions
  40. Document requests and deposition support after a deal
  41. First fairness engagement as an analyst
  42. Associate running the fairness workstream
  43. Serving on the fairness opinion committee
  44. Advising a special committee in a controlling shareholder deal
  45. Opinion when the bank is also the deal adviser
  46. Fairness-only mandates at an independent boutique
  47. Fairness in management buyouts and going-private deals
  48. Solvency and surplus opinions alongside a fairness opinion
  49. Cross-border independent adviser opinions and formal valuations
  50. Fairness opinions on SPAC and de-SPAC mergers

Where it starts.

Each project arrives with its purpose, milestones and first tasks written out. Here is how the first three read.

Scope and limits of a fairness opinion

A fairness opinion says that the consideration in a deal is fair, from a financial point of view, to a defined group of holders as of a stated date, and nothing more. It is not a recommendation on how to vote, a valuation report or a view on whether a higher price was available, and juniors who blur those lines write pages the committee strikes out.

First tasks

  • Pull the opinion letter annexes from three recent merger proxy filings
  • Mark the sentences in each letter that fix scope, holders and date
  • Write the one-page scope and limits note in your own words
  • Ask an associate who has delivered an opinion to check the note

Library of public fairness opinion disclosures

Every public deal that carried an opinion leaves behind the letter, a disclosed summary of the adviser's analyses and usually a paragraph on fees and prior relationships. A library of twenty or thirty of these, tagged by deal type, gives you precedents for which analyses a committee expects, how reference ranges were shown and how conflicts were described, all from material anyone can read.

First tasks

  • Search the securities regulator's filing system for recent merger proxies with opinions
  • Save twenty filings spread across cash, stock and controlling shareholder deals
  • Tag each filing with consideration form, analyses shown and fee disclosure
  • Add the past year's notable fairness disclosures to the library @recurring(yearly)

Fairness engagement letter scope check

The engagement letter fixes who the opinion is addressed to, which holders it covers, whether the bank may decline to give it, the fee and how much of that fee depends on closing. Reading those clauses against the actual deal before anyone starts the book avoids the late discovery that the letter names the full board while the special committee expects the opinion addressed to it.

First tasks

  • Read the draft engagement letter beside the current term sheet
  • Summarise addressee, holders covered, fee and reliance terms on one page
  • Send any clause that does not match the deal to the MD and counsel
  • File the signed letter and the summary in the engagement folder

Make it yours.

Install Fairness Opinions, then tell Aurum the date you're aiming for. It checks whether the plan fits the weeks you actually have.

Free · Mac (Apple silicon) and Windows · v1.0.5 · Other platforms

Blueprints are general information to help you organise your own work. They are not medical, financial, legal or other professional advice. See the Terms.