Each project arrives with its purpose, milestones and first tasks written out. Here is how the first three read.
Engagement acceptance and independence check
Before any work starts, a valuer has to know whether they can be independent of the subject, the client and the likely readers, and whether the firm has the skills and time to do it properly. A written acceptance record, covering conflicts, prior relationships, fee dependence and competence, is the first document an auditor, regulator or opposing counsel will ask to see.
First tasks
- Submit the client, subject and counterparty names to the firm's conflict search
- List any work done for those parties in the last three years
- Confirm the team has the sector and method experience the scope needs
- Record the acceptance decision and get the engagement partner's sign-off
Engagement letter with scope, purpose and intended users
Most valuation disputes trace back to a vague letter: an unclear purpose, unnamed users or a scope that quietly grew. Setting out the subject interest, the purpose, the standard and premise of value, the valuation date, the intended users, the deliverable and the limits on reliance in one signed letter protects both the client and the valuer.
First tasks
- Write a one-line definition of the exact interest being valued
- Draft the purpose, intended users and prohibited uses paragraph
- Send non-standard liability wording to the firm's risk team for review
- Obtain the countersigned letter before any fieldwork starts
Standard of value and premise chosen for the purpose
Fair value for financial reporting, fair market value for tax, investment value for a buyer and the statutory fair value used in some shareholder disputes are different questions with different answers. Fixing the standard and the premise (going concern, orderly or forced liquidation) at the start, with the source that requires it, stops the analysis drifting toward the wrong number.
First tasks
- Find the definition of value in the accounting standard, statute or agreement that applies
- Write the premise of value and why it fits the subject's situation
- Note what the standard implies for control and marketability adjustments
- Send the memo to the client or instructing counsel for written confirmation