Choosing the first paper to replicate
Picking a paper that is too ambitious is the usual reason a first replication stalls in week three. A good first target has a clear method section, data you can actually get, a sample you can run on a laptop and tables with enough detail to check against. Scoring three or four candidates on those points takes an evening and saves months.
First tasks
- List three or four papers you would like to rebuild and note their main tables
- Score each one for data access, method clarity, compute needs and table detail
- Check whether each paper has an online appendix or published code
- Record the chosen paper and the reason it won in your replication folder