Engineering Design Reviews

Stage reviews at 30, 60 and 90 percent, 3D model reviews, operability and constructability input, a comment log with severity codes, and every action closed with a named owner and evidence.

Free · Mac (Apple silicon) and Windows · v1.0.5 · Other platforms

Then open the Marketplace in the app, search for Engineering Design Reviews, and click Install. It goes into your own files, and works offline from then on.

Before you start: this plan is general information to help your team organise its work. It does not replace professional judgement, the rules of your regulator or professional body, your organisation's policies, or advice from a qualified lawyer, accountant or other adviser. Where a law, code or standard applies, use the current official version for your country, and get qualified sign-off on regulated or safety-critical work.

What it installs.

1

Pillar

1

Area

50

Projects

200

Starter tasks

🔧 Engineering Practice

Engineering Design Reviews

Running design reviews at each stage: 30, 60 and 90 percent reviews, 3D model reviews, constructability and operability input, comment logs and closing the actions.

  1. Written design review procedure for the project
  2. Stage gate entry criteria by discipline
  3. Reviewer roster by discipline and stage
  4. Comment log format and severity codes
  5. Design basis baseline for reviewers
  6. Review package assembly checklist
  7. Model review viewer access and markup set-up
  8. Briefing pack for first-time reviewers
  9. Review dates fixed in the engineering schedule
  10. Weekly comment log triage
  11. Review action closure with named owners
  12. Monthly design review metrics report
  13. Interdiscipline check rounds between reviews
  14. Comment response and back-check routine
  15. Weekly 3D model clash report
  16. Holds register on review drawings
  17. Design review lessons learned register
  18. Vendor drawing review turnaround
  19. Reading a P&ID for a design review
  20. Reviewing plot plans and equipment layouts
  21. Writing review comments that get actioned
  22. Chairing a design review meeting
  23. Walking and marking up a 3D model
  24. Operability and maintainability review checklist
  25. Constructability review skills
  26. Human factors in control room and plant layout reviews
  27. Choosing a review markup and comment platform
  28. Fewer review comments through squad checks
  29. Severity code calibration across reviewers
  30. Graded review depth for small and brownfield changes
  31. Moving from drawing sets to model-based review
  32. Design guides from repeat review comments
  33. Clearing a backlog of overdue review actions
  34. Independent design verification or peer check
  35. 30 percent design review
  36. 60 percent 3D model review
  37. 90 percent review and issue for construction readiness
  38. Constructability workshop with the contractor
  39. Operations and maintenance model walk-through
  40. Design review close-out report
  41. First design review as a graduate reviewer
  42. Owner's engineer review of a contractor's design
  43. Design reviews in a small consultancy
  44. Brownfield modification design review
  45. Remote design reviews across offices and time zones
  46. Safety in design review and residual risk record
  47. Audit of the design review process
  48. Model data quality review before handover
  49. Value engineering review at 60 percent
  50. Design review competency matrix for the team

Where it starts.

Each project arrives with its purpose, milestones and first tasks written out. Here is how the first three read.

Written design review procedure for the project

Every project claims to hold design reviews, but without a written procedure each discipline lead runs them differently and nobody can say when a review is finished. A short procedure that names the stages, the attendees, the entry and exit criteria and how comments are closed gives the whole team one rulebook and gives the client something to audit against.

First tasks

  • Collect the client's review requirements from the contract and execution plan
  • Draft the stages, roles and entry criteria on two pages
  • Circulate the draft to discipline leads for one round of comments
  • Issue the approved procedure through document control

Stage gate entry criteria by discipline

Reviewers waste whole days when a 60 percent review arrives with half the piping at 30 percent and the electrical layouts not started. A matrix that states which deliverables each discipline must have at what maturity for each stage lets the review lead refuse an unready package before it eats everyone's time.

First tasks

  • List each discipline's main deliverables from the master deliverables register
  • Write a maturity definition for each deliverable at each review stage
  • Walk the matrix through with each discipline lead in turn
  • Record the go or no-go rule in the review procedure

Reviewer roster by discipline and stage

A review without the right people is a presentation, and the voices most often missing are operations, maintenance and the construction contractor. A roster that names a primary and backup reviewer for each discipline and each stage, including the client's operators, makes it obvious when a seat is empty before the invitation goes out.

First tasks

  • List every discipline and stakeholder group that must review the design
  • Ask the client to name operations and maintenance reviewers
  • Confirm each reviewer's availability for the next review date
  • Refresh the roster for leavers and new joiners @recurring(quarterly)

Make it yours.

Install Engineering Design Reviews, then tell Aurum the date you're aiming for. It checks whether the plan fits the weeks you actually have.

Free · Mac (Apple silicon) and Windows · v1.0.5 · Other platforms

Blueprints are general information to help you organise your own work. They are not medical, financial, legal or other professional advice. See the Terms.